That's because Lily was clearly asking the wrong two people. Her version of Kahlan probably thought the whole thing was adorable.

Not that Cara was going to point that out.

"It also wouldn't be right to let you have the nutcakes I was saving for her while we wait for food," she said instead. "I'll doubt you'd complain about that." If Surreal really wanted them, she'd be here to share the trauma. Besides they were only from J,GoB, Cara wasn't that stupid.